Opinion / James Chambers
Creative control
My abiding memory of the 2019 edition of Art Central in Hong Kong is of an interactive installation by Ko Siu Lan called New Territories, Old Territories. Visitors could turn various Tibetan prayer wheels to spell out the words “Hong Kong is China” or “Hong Kong isn’t China”. At the time, the artwork grabbed headlines. Today it’s not even listed on the artist’s website.
Few galleries will want to push the envelope as the mega fairs Art Basel Hong Kong and its fringe event Art Central get underway today, after being cancelled last year as a result of the pandemic. This will be the first time that either event has taken place under the new security legislation so there’s likely to be even closer scrutiny on what is and isn’t on display. Now that the city’s political opposition has been all but silenced, some underemployed legislators have turned their attention to culture: attacking artworks, questioning acquisitions and calling for institutional heads to roll. Exhibitions have been cancelled by nervous venue heads, film screenings at independent cinemas pulled and foreign talent nudged out of the door.
If Beijing genuinely wants Hong Kong to remain an international cultural hub, it needs to draw a clear line under this patriotic point-scoring before it gets out of control. Hong Kong is still a global art player but other cities could knock it off its pedestal. This week, Frieze picked Seoul for its debut Asian art fair next year. Foreign media titles are already moving to the South Korean capital. Could the art crowd be next? I just hope that politicians from the pro-Beijing camp get a chance to wander the exhibition halls and see the shows for what they are: a huge win for Hong Kong rather than a potential threat to national security.