Feeling the fear - Monocolumn | Monocle


A daily bulletin of news & opinion

8 November 2009

Wander Istanbul at night and probably the worst thing that
 will happen is that you twist your ankle on a wonky pavement. This 
may be a mega-city (population around 12 million) but it is a safe one. Only three people per 100,000 are murdered here each year compared to 21 in 
notoriously dangerous São Paulo. Istanbul’s murder rate is closer to 
London’s (2.2 per 100,000). Yet something odd is going on. People living in Istanbul are more
 scared of being attacked than the residents of São Paulo or London. Some 74 per 
cent say they are afraid of being mugged or physically attacked compared with
47 per cent in Brazil’s financial hub and 38 per cent in the British capital.

There is no single explanation for these figures (produced for the London 
School of Economics Urban Age conference held in Istanbul this week). But it seems that the city’s character as a fast-changing, so-called “hinge city” ­
a place of transition, with enormous flows of people passing through in
search of work ­ has something to do with it.

One effect of this exaggerated fear of being attacked is that
Istanbulites love their cars. Vast numbers drive to work even though it can add hours (not to mention stress) to the daily commute 
(especially if you’re stuck in the daily bottle neck on a bridge over the 

Another statistic ­ 85 per cent of offices are on the European side of the 
city but 70 per cent of office workers live on the Asian side, according to
 Orhan Esen, a researcher and city guide. That’s a lot of people crossing 
the Bosphorus every day to get to work.

“The car is still a status symbol here,” says Haluk Gercek, professor of 
transport at Istanbul Tech University. “It’s a symbol of freedom. But it’s 
also about safety. When people get into their SUV, they feel safe.”
 He warns though that building more bridges, flyovers and highways has never
 helped decongest a city. It just encourages more people to use their cars.

For this reason, and for the environmental damage it could cause, many oppose the city government’s proposal to build a third bridge 
linking the eastern and western sides of the city.

So how else can they end the traffic jams? It will be hard to convince the
 residents of Istanbul to take to their bicycles or walk – there are too many 
hills for one thing. But the growing pressure to protect the environment and reduce car 
use means this city will have to find a solution. Maybe if something was
 done to make people less afraid of the people around them, they might just jump on the nearest tram or ferry. 


sign in to monocle

new to monocle?

Subscriptions start from £120.

Subscribe now





Monocle Radio


  • Konfekt Korner