Opinion / Rhys James
State of independence
Two of the UK’s Labour Party-supporting heartlands are being placed under fresh lockdown restrictions today. Wales, which has a population of about three million, will do so of its own volition as its devolved powers allow it to take control of some of its own affairs without any input from central government in London. Greater Manchester, meanwhile, which has a similar number of inhabitants as Wales but no such autonomy, is being coerced into its stoppage by the Conservative government – and it’s unclear when the restrictions will be lifted.
The standoff in the north-west of England has made for uncomfortable viewing. Manchester’s mayor, Andy Burnham, resisted Westminster’s attempts to enforce a lockdown and even the city’s right-wing representatives fought his corner. By contrast, Mark Drakeford, the first minister of Wales, doesn’t need Westminster’s permission to act – or indeed to do nothing. His plans to impose a “short, sharp” two-week lockdown might yet provide a blueprint for other regions in the UK.
So could the Welsh experience encourage demands for greater Mancunian autonomy? Wales took decades to warm to the idea, overwhelmingly rejecting devolution in a 1979 referendum. But in 1997 I remember staying up on a school night to watch its wafer-thin acceptance of the proposal; and then, as a fledgling radio producer in 2011, I covered the referendum on expanding the Welsh parliament’s remit. That last result was emphatic, as 63.5 per cent of voters backed direct law-making powers for the country.
Devolution, of course, isn’t a silver bullet. It requires effective leadership and buy-in from the electorate that it aims to serve. But it is curious that the Welsh seem happier than the Mancunians as they head into their respective lockdowns. It might just be that the Welsh are safe in the knowledge that decisions on their collective health and livelihoods are being taken much closer to home.