Opinion / Henry Rees-Sheridan
Polls apart
Today’s US presidential election will function as the climax of what has been the most tumultuous year of Donald Trump’s first term. The defining events of 2020 have been the spread of coronavirus and the Black Lives Matter protests. The nature of their origins couldn’t be more different: the source of Covid-19 is a viral adaptive process that we have little control over, whereas the demonstrations are a response to the completely human phenomenon of systemic racism. But our reactions to both of them have shaped the political landscape in which this election is taking place.
The Black Lives Matter movement might as well have been designed in a lab to function as a wedge issue among Americans. Addressing some of the most sensitive and troubling aspects of the country’s history, it elicits wildly different and almost universally strong feelings. The protests and counter protests have only brought into relief the fact that this election will serve as a referendum on the most fundamental aspects of the nation’s identity.
In contrast, coronavirus, which poses a potentially deadly threat to anyone and everyone, might have been designed to bring the country together in demanding a unified and largely technical response. But here, as in many other places, it has had nearly the opposite effect. President Trump politicised the virus from the off and played down its threat, even while being hospitalised with it. That’s one of the reasons that Americans are entering into this election experiencing about the same level of cognitive dissonance as they were when exiting the last one.
However, both despite and because of the febrile political atmosphere, Americans are turning up to vote. Turnout is on course to surpass 150 million for the first time in history. This is in itself a vote of confidence in US democracy and an act of faith in the promise of free and fair elections. If this faith turns out to have been misplaced – if the election is compromised by foreign interference, domestic malfeasance, procedural incompetence or a cocktail of those factors – then it’s likely that the immediate response will be an escalation of civil unrest. The police are preparing for this, as are shops across the country, many of which have boarded up their windows. Longer term, a mishandled election or a contested result could leave scars on the nation’s psyche that will be deep enough to last for generations.