Opinion / Josh Fehnert
Leading the line
A man in rolled-up shirtsleeves is holding a sledgehammer in front of a slate-grey concrete slab in the shape of Texas. A voiceover informs us that Democratic gubernatorial candidate Beto O’Rourke – played by an actor with his back to us who is now hoisting the hammer menacingly – will destroy the Lone Star State if he is elected instead of the two-term Republican incumbent, Greg Abbott.
Despite the slick production, this attack ad, aired ahead of the midterm elections yesterday, felt like a sad reflection on political discourse in the US: adversarial, oddly personal and keener on pointing out differences than any common ground. And that’s not to mention the ever-present threat of violence.
The Monocle team has been observing the electioneering and division up close in Dallas, where we have come for The Chiefs, our conference about leadership and how to improve our lives and livelihoods. Last night we heard from the city’s charismatic Democratic mayor, Eric Johnson, about the challenges that the fast-growing metropolis faces, as well as its opportunities. Today we’ll speak to the executive editor of The Dallas Morning News, Katrice Hardy, about the importance of being balanced, telling the truth and serving your community. Both represent a diversity of thought, serious leadership and a sincere search for ways of doing things better in a divided US.
Back in the attack ad, the salt-and-pepper-haired O’Rourke character has pummelled the concrete Texas into debris – having raised taxes and freed all of the criminals, as the ad warned us that he might. As for Abbott, on whose behalf the ad was aired? I sense that he’s more concerned with battering his rivals and besmirching their reputations than talking about his policies.
The point that really needs hammering home? At their best, good leaders listen, are constructive, try to patch up divisions and bolt together agreements – even if that means working with people who disagree with them. They don’t smash things to smithereens, then check what’s left when the dust settles.
Josh Fehnert is Monocle’s editor. Listen to Monocle 24 for our coverage of the US midterm results.