Opinion / Christopher Cermak
Poll positions
Listening to candidates and voters ahead of the US midterm elections, it was easy to forget the dire rhetoric on the airwaves about the looming end of American democracy. When I joined a Pennsylvania state House candidate, Anna Thomas, for a final afternoon of door-knocking, people focused on more tangible things: high prices and abortion, for example, but also personal problems. Thomas told me that she had connected more than one voter with a local lawyer. It felt like a return to a more traditional kind of politics: that of a pre-Trump, pre-social-media age, when community connections mattered.
Thomas didn’t win on Tuesday, though I’m sure that she’ll be back. But her party, the Democrats, swept the key races for the Senate and governor in Pennsylvania, a crucial battleground state. One reason for this is that character evidently still matters, along with a local touch. John Fetterman (pictured), the hoodie-wearing populist Democrat who has won a hard-fought Senate seat, made much of the fact that his Donald Trump-backed opponent, celebrity doctor Mehmet Oz, was from the neighbouring state of New Jersey.
What happened in Pennsylvania is symptomatic of another trend. US voters have a hunger for fresh faces and anti-establishment candidates but not necessarily brash celebrities who parachute into politics. Sports stars and news anchors – even a former weatherman – who entered races generally underperformed. We have been there and done that, and are ready for something new. Whether that comes from the left or right is less clear. The governor of Florida, Ron DeSantis, was re-elected by a landslide after presenting himself as a hard-right candidate without some of Trump’s personal character flaws. Also impressive was the re-election of Gavin Newsom, California’s left-leaning governor.
A final, heartening lesson of these elections is that reports of American democracy’s imminent death might have been greatly exaggerated. Election-denying candidates did less well than expected, while state and local officials deserve praise for running a smooth vote in a threatening, highly partisan atmosphere. With any luck, the madness of 2020 was an outlier rather than the new normal for US elections. We can only hope.
Christopher Cermak is Monocle’s Washington correspondent. Listen to Monocle 24 for our coverage of the US midterm results.