Opinion / Andrew Mueller
Making a fist of it
At the 1968 Summer Olympics in Mexico City, US sprinters Tommie Smith and John Carlos mounted the podium to receive the gold and bronze medals that they had respectively won in the men’s 200m race. As The Star-Spangled Banner played, both athletes raised a gloved fist in a Black Power salute (pictured). They did so at considerable cost to their careers (silver medallist Peter Norman of Australia was also ostracised for his support of the Americans). They understood and accepted that effective protest is rarely a risk-free option.
Little of such fortitude has thus far been displayed at the Fifa World Cup Qatar 2022. Earlier this week, football’s governing body announced that any captain who consummated a promise to wear a rainbow-striped “One Love” armband on the pitch would be subject to a yellow card. The football associations of England, Wales and several other countries promptly buckled, revealing themselves as willing to take a principled stand only when there was no footballing cost attached. Qatari authorities, apparently emboldened, began confiscating from fans any items adorned with a rainbow motif.
At this early stage, the World Cup is making everybody involved look as good as might have been expected: the hosts like authoritarian weirdos, the guests like craven supplicants. We are such a distance through the looking glass that the prime moral exemplars are the team representing Iran; the subtext to their decision not to sing the country’s anthem prior to kick-off was unmistakable and the risk that they were running was considerable.
The idea that sport can be detached from politics has always been risible, especially where international sport is concerned; it was for political reasons that Qatar bid for the World Cup in the first place. The Gulf state might have calculated that the soft-power benefits would compensate for the criticism – Russia got away with it in 2018, after all. But people knew and admired things about Russia’s past, if not its present. This is – Qatar Airways and Al Jazeera notwithstanding – Qatar’s bow on the world stage. They might have anticipated a different response.
Andrew Mueller is host of ‘The Foreign Desk’ on Monocle 24. For more analysis of the politics surrounding the World Cup, you can tune in here.