Opinion / Gregory Scruggs
At the water’s edge
Manhattan has 51km of shoreline but, until Gansevoort Peninsula opened a few weeks ago, it didn’t have a beach. Piers and seawalls have long created a protective perimeter around the New York borough. With this new addition to the Hudson River Park, however, the water’s edge now beckons. The waterfront space – a joint commission from the state and city governments – is roughly the size of four American football fields and offers plenty of amenities. Designed by Field Operations, the New York-based studio behind the High Line, it includes boardwalks, a sports field, a beach, a large seating lawn, a picnic area and a salt marsh.
When I visited on a windswept day shortly after its opening, a few people were picking their way down a rocky escarpment to marvel at the peninsula’s landscape at low tide. The park is helping Manhattanites to connect with the natural world, reminding them that they are islanders in a great estuary, on a tidal river that rises and falls.
But things could be done to strengthen this link. Near the shoreline is a sign that reads, “No swimming”. It’s a stern visual cue signalling that this well-designed intervention’s success remains at the mercy of the wider ecosystem’s health. While the Hudson is safer for swimming than it has been in decades, the perception and reality of pollution make the public averse to taking a dip. If local authorities want Field Operations’ work to live up to its potential, they must maintain good water quality and invite New Yorkers to swim. Until then, the landscape, with its sandy beach, artfully arranged beach umbrellas and Adirondack-style chairs, will be little more than a well-designed prop for would-be beachgoers.
Design interventions of this kind can only be fully complete when they exist within healthy and functioning environments. Just as no man is an island, no landscape is one either.
Gregory Scruggs is a regular contributor to ‘Monocle on Design’. For more opinion, analysis and insight, subscribe to Monocle today.