Opinion / Christopher Cermak
No exceptions
Those of us living in stable Western democracies tend to maintain a simple belief about the darker sides of governance: “It can’t happen here.” Instead we look at the rise of populists, authoritarians or even just plain-old bumbling politicians in other countries with a mix of horror and bemusement, and scoff, “We would never have elected them.” That’s because populists and nationalists tend to be, well, nation-specific: Silvio Berlusconi would never have succeeded in Hungary; Viktor Orbán would have flopped in the UK; and Boris Johnson wouldn’t have made it, well, anywhere else.
So now the entire world is looking in horror towards the US – once a beacon of democracy – as its reputation lies in tatters after supporters of Donald Trump stormed the US Capitol on Wednesday; four people died in the incident. Many global leaders condemned the insurrection as, to paraphrase Emmanuel Macron, “un-American”. Many Americans, including me, can only bow their heads and agree. We too couldn’t help but ask as we watched the scenes unfold, “How did this happen here”?
Perhaps it’s this very notion of exceptionalism that is the biggest threat to any and every Western democracy today; it leads us to be blind to, or dismissive of, any attack on our freedoms. Rationally, we all understood that the bitter rhetoric of the past four years under Trump, and the bitter politicisation of our nation that began long before he entered the political stage, made it inevitable that violence would ensue. And yet still, in our hearts, many of us never really believed that it would come to this. Perhaps the lesson, then, is that we should all acknowledge – before it’s too late – that it could happen anywhere.