Opinion / James Chambers
Changing channel
When two million people took to the streets in Hong Kong in 2019, I was watching CNN from a hotel room in Beijing. Every time the presenter mentioned Hong Kong the screen would go black, miraculously returning as soon as the segment was over. This happened again and again as CNN repeated its daily news cycle. The cutaways were so blatant that no guests would have bothered banging the TV in frustration or calling down to reception. Most foreign media is blocked in China and even channels that are available in international hotels are subject to censorship and delayed transmissions. Therefore, the news last week that the BBC World Service has been banned in China gives a misleading impression. Ordinary Chinese were never able to view the channel anyway. And, no, the BBC’s latest report on the shocking treatment of the Uyghurs in Xinjiang has not been viewed widely.
Somewhat counterintuitively, the bigger question is: why not more? Beijing moved only after the UK communications regulator took China’s own state-owned broadcaster CGTN off air for violating its licence, and responded more with face-saving rhetoric than genuine fury. Similar restraint followed the UK government’s offer of citizenship to almost half of Hong Kong: China announced that it would no longer recognise British National Overseas passports as travel documents, simply reflecting the status quo for the majority of holders.
By contrast, London has been taking a tougher line with China lately, starting with the restrictions on telecoms operator Huawei. But the blowback so far has been minimal. Where are the nationalistic boycotts of British products? Where are the arrests of British business executives on trumped-up spying charges? Where, in short, is the Australia treatment? Canberra is still in the doghouse for daring to support an independent investigation into the origins of coronavirus. Quick to take offence, China can sometimes be slow to exact revenge. Beijing clearly wants cordial relations with the UK right now but Whitehall should be watching closely: a diplomatic blackout could come at any time.