Opinion / Nic Monisse
Growing pains
The role of a city government is much like that of a parent with teenagers – but with the municipality itself as its offspring. For a city to thrive, it needs permission to explore, play and push limits but firm boundaries still need to be set. With this in mind, New York City Hall (a well-respected parent) has finally caved in to its children’s demands by trialling dockless scooters in parts of the city this summer. No doubt peer pressure played a part (we can hear the cries of “all my friends are doing it”) given that NYC is the last major US metropolis to permit the likes of Lime, Bird and VeoRide to operate on its streets.
I know that it’s taboo to be critical of someone else’s parenting, especially when you don’t have children of your own, but this particular indulgence is unwise. It’s not that dockless e-scooters themselves are bad – anything that might potentially get people out of their cars is a good thing – but rather the way that they are ridden on pavements at high speed and also how they are parked: without docking stations they’re often strewn across footpaths, making it impossible for anyone with a pram or wheelchair to move comfortably. The net result then, for any city that permits them, is often to the detriment of pedestrians and streetlife.
At the very least, the city should demand that e-scooter companies introduce docking stations so that the new toys can be put away properly after use and our pavements are cleared. But perhaps I’m not giving New York’s parenting enough credit. If its citizens don’t behave properly on the scooters this summer, the government might yet invoke the age-old parental motto: if you don’t use it properly, you’re not allowed to have it.