Opinion / Ed Stocker
Protest vote
One of the great mistakes of the early days of reporting on Trumpism was to lump all of the former US president’s supporters into a uniform bloc. In the run-up to the Italian elections on 25 September, it would be easy to do the same when looking at the backers of the right-wing Fratelli d’Italia party, led by Giorgia Meloni (pictured). She is someone who has rallied in opposition to the “LGBT lobby” and declared a need for a “naval blockade” against illegal immigrants. Surely all of her supporters have extreme views?
While Meloni is clearly a far-right candidate, many will be voting for her for reasons that have little to do with immigration or LGBT rights. There are those who will do so simply because they don’t feel represented by any of Italy’s other squabbling politicians. Meloni can paint herself as an outsider, having not dirtied her hands in any of the nation’s recent disastrous coalitions. Many believe that she could soon be the country’s prime minister, even if polls suggest that about 42 per cent of voters are undecided about who to support.
There was no talk of naval blockades in a recent debate between Meloni and the Democratic Party’s schoolmasterly secretary, Enrico Letta, hosted by newspaper Corriere della Sera’s streaming channel on Monday. Instead, her discourse centred on European agreements and migration-processing camps in third-party nations – controversial, perhaps, but tested in Australia and on the cards for the UK.
While Meloni’s bid to appear more moderate should be taken with a pinch of salt, her popularity is a reaction to a broken political system. The anti-establishment Five Star Movement became the nation’s principal party in 2018 because people were fed up with traditional politicians. The same could happen this time around but the consequences would be altogether more serious.
Ed Stocker is Monocle’s European editor at large, based in Milan.