Opinion / James Chambers
Speaking out
We might only be in February but it already looks as though 2023 will be a tough year for press freedom in Asia. Earlier this week a court in Bangladesh upheld a government order to shut down Dainik Dinkal, the country’s main opposition newspaper. The decision in Dhaka follows a similar crackdown in Cambodia and a raid on the BBC’s offices (pictured) in India by tax officials, not long after the British broadcaster aired an unflattering documentary about the country’s prime minister, Narendra Modi. All of these nations are holding elections in the next year.
That should be all the more reason to allow for alternative points of view. “The space for free speech should permit the most fierce criticism and accusations, especially when the target is the authorities,” said journalist Chung Pui-kuen during his sedition trial in Hong Kong a few weeks ago. The city’s government doesn’t seem to agree: Hong Kong continues to slide down the World Press Freedom Index, though at a dismal 148 out of 180 it still manages to hover above India at 150. It’s a useful reminder that democracy alone is no guarantee of free speech. Here in Bangkok, we have been receiving daily updates about the deteriorating health of two young activists who went on hunger strike to protest against the country’s strict lèse-majesté laws.
All of this is alarming for journalists across the continent. But if there’s a glimmer of hope, it’s thanks to those who refuse to pipe down. The last word should go to Maria Ressa, a thorn in the side of the Philippines’ former president Rodrigo Duterte and an icon of free speech in the region. After winning a trumped-up tax-evasion trial in January, Ressa said: “Today, facts win, truth wins, justice wins.” Let’s hope that it wasn’t a one off.
James Chambers is Monocle’s Asia editor, based in Bangkok. To read more of his reports from the region, subscribe to Monocle.