When will it end? Though the worst of the coronavirus pandemic might be well and truly over, it seems that some populations are not moving on. On recent trips to Australia and the US, I noticed that design interventions that were devised as necessary, short-term solutions to allow us to operate at the height of the pandemic are now permanent, blighting everything from streetscapes to restaurant interiors.
Last summer, New York’s mayor, Eric Adams, signed a bill into law that made permanent the city’s outdoor-dining programme, in which restaurants across the five boroughs built makeshift shelters for dining. The outcome is that Mulberry Street is now lined with ugly tin shacks, while establishments across the city force patrons to eat in little more than a tent. Imagine booking a table at a high-end restaurant, only to find out that you’re going to be served your eastern oysters and chenin blanc in what amounts to a wigwam.
The situation in the US might be bad but it’s not as dire as it is in Australia. On a tour of Sydney’s café scene, I observed countless beautiful tables blighted by glued-on QR codes. Not only do these Perspex squares make the table surface uneven and limit space (you can’t put a bowl or glass near them) but they also encourage everyone to have their phones out on the table, killing the atmosphere.
Sadly, this isn’t the first time that I have witnessed an ill-considered design craze take over our cities. The 2010s saw the rise of tactical urbanism, a movement in which guerrilla activists installed low-cost temporary interventions in the built environment. It was a well-meaning initiative that resulted in everything from makeshift bike lanes to pocket parks being installed in cities. While they were effective in promoting discussions about how we want our cities to work, these should have eventually been removed. Instead, many were left in place permanently, resulting in decaying parklets made from hay bales and untreated railway sleepers, and unsealed bike lanes that faded into oblivion. They have ended up lowering the quality of the streets that they aimed to improve.
The same can be said of these pandemic-related interventions. They were called temporary at the time and making them permanent has only served to diminish our quality of life. New York and Sydney – you’re better than this.