Opinion / Josh Fehnert
Signal failure
New York’s Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) has a platform to create safer spaces – but it needs to be quick if it’s to avoid missing its stop. As reported below, the MTA is mulling over how to use its vacant retail spaces. On the roster of (rather drab) ideas that the MTA has mooted: making room for display advertising, plonking down vending machines or simply clearing more room for passengers on the platforms. Oh dear.
One unintended consequence of removing people from the equation is the loss of security that an extra pair of eyes offers. A key urbanism lesson is that once you begin stripping people from public spaces – and start creating purely residential areas or financial districts – it creates an uneasy vacuum after dark. It’s a scenario that lends itself to crime and vandalism, not to mention an over-reliance on CCTV cameras (usually better at decoding what went wrong rather than preventing it). The same goes for station platforms. It feels safer to be in a place where there’s a person manning a kiosk, as opposed to an empty platform with a vending machine blinking at you. Leasing these spaces to people running independent businesses (or to design students or makers) would be just the ticket for the MTA.