Opinion / Andrew Tuck
Capital loss
Indonesia’s president Joko Widodo has apparently taken the decision to move the country’s capital – this is a mistake. Jakarta is justifiably regarded as one of the most chaotic, traffic-clogged, polluted cities in the world – and one that’s sinking to boot – but as long as it’s a big mess it should remain the capital. Why?
Too often national governments fail to bring in the urban policies needed to create sustainable cities and then, when they see the misery of their failures through their ministerial limo windows, they panic and flee. That’s why in Egypt the government is saying farewell to Cairo and why Burma’s generals and ministers have said adieu to Rangoon and set up shop in the technocrats’ nirvana of Naypyidaw. The urge to desert mess for order also created Kano and Brasilía.
Governments should not be allowed to run away from their mismanagement so easily. But the citizens of the old capitals usually have the last laugh because new cities built around civil servants are always boring. Just wait to see how many government officials will be jumping on the Friday afternoon shuttle back to Jakarta in years to come.