Opinion / Robert Bound
Different points of view
What are entertainers worth compared to journalists? About £10,200 (€12,000) more per hour – or £2,600 (€3,000) per 15 minutes – if one side of a landmark equal-pay case in the UK is to be believed. Samira Ahmed, a journalist who has presented widely across the BBC on TV and radio, is taking the BBC to court claiming almost £700,000 (€812,000) in underpayment for her work on Newswatch, a programme that deals with audience complaints about news coverage. Her lawyers argue that it is similar enough to Points of View – a cosier audience-feedback show – formerly presented by UK broadcaster Jeremy Vine. Ahmed was paid £440 (€510) per programme, Vine £3,000 (€3,500). Both shows are less than 15 minutes long.
The BBC has said that the programmes vary enough in their style, content and viewing figures – not to mention the channels on which they air – for the comparison to be unrealistic. The BBC is right: Ahmed has mostly stuck to news while Vine presents a hugely popular midday music-and-chat show on BBC Radio 2. Vine, annoying as some may find him, is a talented journalist who has successfully swung to entertainment for a tidy sum.
Ahmed may be expecting the force-eight gale of the much-reported “gender pay gap” to put wind in the sails of her case but the tribunal would be wise to resist this weather. Most likely, Ahmed and Vine were paid what they were worth in a media marketplace in which news is simply worth less than entertainment. Ahmed needs a better agent. The rest of us? We’re all searching for that job that only lasts 15 minutes (stop sniggering at the back).