Opinion / Nic Monisse
Find the Wright place
The streets of Chicago’s North Shore neighbourhoods were treated to a rare sight last week: a Frank Lloyd Wright home sitting on the back of a truck. In a move that’s likely to delight enthusiasts of the modernist master’s canon, Booth Cottage, which was built in 1913 as a temporary house for Wright’s lawyer, has been saved from demolition and is instead being relocated to a nearby park.
But it’s a plan that will disappoint architectural purists who believe that moving a building for the purposes of conservation undermines its heritage value. Normally I’m inclined to agree: good architecture should be tied to place, taking cues from its context and responding to it. At it’s best, it should become an irreplaceable part of the landscape; imagine Wright’s Fallingwater (pictured) anywhere other than at its plot in rural Pennsylvania, replete with creeks and streams, and it loses its majesty.
Despite all this, the decision to move Booth Cottage could be a good thing: removing and relocating a building in appropriate surroundings could turn it into an artefact of sorts. (That’s an idea worth keeping in mind for the ongoing discussion over what to do with controversial statues). So plans to turn Booth Cottage into a museum at its new location seem apt. In terms of what to display inside, I’d suggest drawings and photographs of significant buildings lost to the wrecking ball: Wright’s W Carr Cottage in Michigan and Lockridge Medical Clinic in Montana would be a fitting start.