Opinion / Christopher Cermak
Neighbourhood watch
The German love of rules is a subject of much parody abroad but in reality it’s a relationship that is far more nuanced than the popular stereotype. Yes, Germany is a country where the rules are many and adherence to them must often be to the letter (unless you’re in free-minded Berlin, which takes a more lackadaisical Mediterranean-style approach). But there’s a caveat: adherence to rules doesn’t always mean that policing them is up to the state.
Ensuring that rules are followed is more of a community-based, peer-pressure sort of thing: make too much noise after 22.00 or start drilling holes into your walls on a Sunday (yes, it’s against the rules) and you might get a knock on the door and a rude telling-off from one of your neighbours. On the plus side, you’re less likely to have the police show up at your door. Memories of the former East German Republic, where state police actively encouraged people to report on their neighbours, still ring true for many in Germany, breeding a healthy scepticism of state involvement when a community solution is more obvious.
Why mention this now? Because the new pandemic-related restrictions introduced in the UK yesterday limiting gatherings to six people or fewer came with a rather shocking encouragement from the UK’s minister of state for crime and policing: neighbours should feel “open” to calling a non-emergency hotline if they see people violating the new rules. That feels like a slippery slope. Yes, we need sensible rules to help combat this virus and they should be followed – but neighbours reporting on each other? Surely it’s better to do this the frank German way and keep the telling-off within the confines of the neighbourhood.