Opinion / Josh Fehnert
Talking trash
City living can be a grotty business. Over the past week, Paris’s leaders have borne the brunt of a social media campaign under the hashtag “Saccage Paris” (“Paris destroyed”), which dolefully depicts streets strewn with rubbish, overflowing bins, graffiti and general disrepair across the French capital. The trash talk is being levelled against the governing Socialist Party leadership and has been used by its detractors to imply a wider malaise. The political message in a limited number of characters? That the civic leadership is rubbish.
On the far right, Marine Le Pen says that the issue shows the “decay” of Paris, while the city’s left-leaning deputy mayor Emmanuel Grégoire tried to sweep the issue under the carpet by noting that all major cities have similar issues with sanitation and pointing the finger at London. The truth – judging by the flotsam, jetsam and brimming bins in the UK capital – is that he’s right. Paris, like many stretched and increasingly cash-strapped cities, is struggling with the fallout from increased home deliveries, a packaging boom from populations broadly confined to their homes and a lack of bins (and toilets) in public spaces.
Most intriguing to me is Grégoire’s suggestion this week on French radio station RTL that “if you take a picture every day of the worst moment of your daily life, that isn’t reality”. Maybe Monsieur Grégoire is technically correct: these images don’t show nuance or the cleaner corners of the city. But the sentiment shows a naiveté about the social media-run world in which he’s governing. He and his party will need to address the issue and clean up the streets to restore the party’s reputation. More broadly, though, the issue of sanitation in our cities isn’t just a Paris problem.