Opinion / Christopher Cermak
Constructive thinking
Visit Aceh in Indonesia today and you wouldn’t know that it suffered a devastating tsunami in 2005, Ani Dasgupta of the World Resources Institute tells me. A key reason for this was Indonesia’s impressive ownership of the reconstruction process. International organisations provided assistance, including the World Bank, where Dasgupta was an envoy at the time. “But it was absolutely clear to every one of us, including me, that we were helping them reconstruct,” says Dasgupta.
By contrast, Jed Horne, former city editor of The Times-Picayune newspaper in New Orleans, tells me of the infighting and corruption that followed Hurricane Katrina in 2005. “There was tremendous tension,” he says, coupled with a lack of understanding of what residents needed. New Orleans has mostly recovered today but that is thanks more to neighbourhood and civil society efforts than to government leadership.
Ukraine’s leaders appear to have taken those lessons about the need for national ownership to heart. “All of the initiatives, plans and ambitions for recovery must be part of a single system, where not only the needs but the feelings of Ukrainians will be at the forefront,” president Volodymyr Zelensky told the Ukraine Recovery Conference in Lugano in a video address yesterday. And Ukraine’s prime minister, Denys Shmyhal (pictured), who attended in person, outlined a detailed draft rebuilding plan “to show that Ukraine has a very clear vision of how we can become successful”.
The question is whether the EU and others have listened. Zelensky’s remark about the need for a “single system” was a not-so-subtle rebuke of an EU-led platform to co-ordinate the rebuilding effort. “Ukraine will be in the lead,” EU Commission president Ursula Von der Leyen promised as she unveiled the platform. If past reconstruction efforts are anything to go by, that had better be true.
Christopher Cermak is Monocle’s news editor. Hear more from Aceh, New Orleans and Lugano during a special series on ‘The Monocle Daily’ on Monocle 24 throughout this week.