Opinion / David Hodari
Better in than out
I was eating dinner in London’s Soho with a friend who runs operations for a chain of restaurants. It wasn’t haute cuisine but the establishment we were in had inspired rave reviews from the city’s dinnerati. Our enthusiastic but chaotic young waiter maintained a vaguely threatening presence near our table, coming over every couple of minutes to offer his assistance (were we ready to order? Had we finished our main courses?). The subpar experience prompted my friend to vent about the nightmares of finding staff after the pandemic and Brexit. “The British think that they’re too good for service jobs,” he said. “And if you tell people who will do them to ‘go home’ enough times, they eventually will.”
The arguments around Brexit are well documented. Added to those are inflation, the war in Ukraine and supply-chain snarl-ups that are simultaneously raising the cost of living and limiting our ability to move cargo and ourselves between countries. All of this has brought into focus a problem that has been brewing in the world’s wealthiest countries for a generation – even as responses wildly differ. This week, Portugal’s government moved to relax visa restrictions for fellow Lusophone countries, while Germany is reforming its immigration system to ease its worker shortage. Japan, however, continues to suffer from an ageing yet historically immigration-averse population.
Without immigration, we’re all heading in Japan’s direction. UK census data shows that there are now more people aged 65 and over in England and Wales than children under the age of 15. Despite this, the contenders to be the UK’s next prime minister seem resolutely anti-immigration, echoing the political debate that has been seen in both France and the US in recent years. They should instead be making a positive case for the more considered and systematic immigration policy that’s clearly needed. Wealthy nations face a stark choice. Following the lead of Portugal and Germany by becoming more hospitable to foreigners would be a good place to start.
David Hodari is Monocle’s business editor.