Opinion / Ed Stocker
Man in the middle
It was universally recognised that Angela Merkel, Germany’s former chancellor, would be difficult to follow. That’s not to say that she exuded charisma – the contrary – but she projected competence and professionalism, and an unwavering belief in the European project. Her successor, 64-year-old Olaf Scholz, marks a year in office early next month. On the surface, Scholz (pictured, on right, with Merkel) and “Mutti” seem to share many attributes, with an unflappable and almost teacherly desire to get on with the job. But some key differences in their world views mean that his leadership has been, at times, confused and lacking in dynamism.
The most notable example has been his go-it-alone approach to energy prices. France’s Emmanuel Macron has been pushing for a more cohesive, bloc-wide answer (something that one feels Merkel might have endorsed) but in July, Scholz announced €200bn in funds for German households and businesses to subsidise gas prices.
Of course, Scholz faces problems that Merkel didn’t: a cost-of-living crisis, a war in Europe and the heightened threats of Russia and China. But even in that context, his decision to visit China today – not long after the Communist Party congress highlighted the country’s further descent into autocracy – has proven controversial. While his predecessor made the trip 12 times during her chancellorship (and received criticism for her own business-friendly approach towards Beijing), Scholz’s similar attitude has failed to recognise that the word has changed in a short space of time. Stark questions remain over why he’s undermining the US’s and other European nations’ stronger stance against China.
So will strong German leadership in Europe and the wider world continue? Scholz heads a sometimes fractious coalition and the popularity of his Social Democrats party has plummeted. That suggests he might be more focused on polling figures in 2023 than maintaining Germany’s leadership role in the international community. The world will be worse off for it.
Ed Stocker is Monocle’s Europe editor-at-large.