The Faster Lane / Tyler Brûlé
World of difference
Does anyone know what happened to February? Did it fall between cushions on the sofa? Did it melt under the warm winter skies? Or did it just disappear because January was a bit of a slow starter and things only started to move over the past few weeks? Today’s column is being tapped out on my balcony up in St Moritz under clear, warm, sunny skies that feel very much like early April rather than the end of February. In a couple of hours we’ll be hosting a little cocktail party on the terrace at the Hotel Steffani to mark the arrival of the Nomad art fair in St Moritz and at about this time on Sunday (10.00am CET), I’ll be settling in behind the mic with my colleague Chiara Rimella for a special two-hour edition of Monocle on Sunday. If you want to get a high-altitude take on the state of the art market and more, then please tune in.
This week involved a lot of rail time (London to Paris, Paris to Bern, Bern to Zürich) and that meant many hours spent looking out of the window, taking stock of the first few weeks of the year and assessing the stark differences between the Americas, Europe and Asia in this slightly altered world. Off the back of my North America tour in mid-January, I penned a column about the problem with the work-from-home free-for-all, its effect on cities and the role that companies have within their communities. It was no surprise that it generated plenty of correspondence but what was striking is that it also proved a theory that there’s a sizeable pocket of the Anglosphere (New Zealand, Australia, the UK, Canada, the US and their expat communities) that doesn’t want to hear opposing ideas, aren’t interested in different perspectives and are quite prone to angry language if you step outside the prevailing narrative.
A sizeable pocket of the Anglosphere (New Zealand, Australia, the UK, Canada, the US and their expat communities) doesn’t want to hear opposing ideas
If I could have put this into an infographic, it went from the first time zones (New Zealand and Australia) being generally upset that I might raise a few critical questions about withering business districts and then on to readers in Singapore and Hong Kong being in favour of functioning urban cores. After a few hours, Europeans started opening their newsletters and the response chimed with Asia: there were plenty of business owners and salaried staffers who said that they liked the rhythm and importance of office life and urban vibrancy. After that it was mostly angry letters from the UK all the way to the US west coast, with no one wanting their new routine upset and many arguing that city cores were dying anyway, so it is best just to leave them to rot. In a few instances, I had to question whether some were really fully paid-up Monocle readers but I’m always happy to engage. In a couple of cases, I think I managed to get our readers to at least start examining a new take on how our cities might be unravelling (at speed) rather than shutting down the notion altogether.
“The concept of inclusion and diversity is a very American invention,” said a Singapore lawmaker during my recent visit. “And it’s being forced on nations and businesses that operate by different codes for a variety of reasons: historical values and circumstance, religion, geography and more. Not recognising these differences and trying to force a US liberal agenda through Indonesian society in itself is not very inclusive.”
Over several lunches and dinners in various Asian cities, I also heard parents and policymakers saying that there’s a rethink going on around the status of sending sons and daughters to US institutions. “It’s one thing to send people with master’s degrees or doctorates to the US for degrees when their view of the world might be more fully formed and they’re secure in their convictions but I’m not sure whether many people want their children going over to the US straight out of high school,” said a friend over lunch in Singapore.
Could it be that Asian conservatism and Germanic pragmatism is acting as a much-needed buffer to the Anglosphere’s culture of intolerant tolerance? Have new, well-funded media outlets revealed that the supremacy of established news organisations is far from guaranteed? Are we seeing slivers of courage where politicians, business owners and journalists choose to use cold, hard data to call out missteps in municipal policies and federally funded programmes? And could it be that the climate where too many were constantly on watch for signs of the slightest offence is moving on to a place of reason, understanding and forgiveness? Here’s hoping.