Opinion / Fiona Wilson
Korea advice
Seoul is heading for a rebrand and it has been asking the public for its opinion. Yet looking for consensus among online voters might be unwise. The South Korean capital turned to the public the last time around – and the jury is still out on the result: “I.Seoul.U” has been the city’s awkward tagline since 2015.
Last December, Seoul’s metropolitan government invited citizens to pick a new slogan that would best help it to “take a leap forward as a global city”. The four epithets on offer were: “Seoul for you”, “Seoul, my soul”, “Amazing Seoul” and – surely not – “Make it happen, Seoul”.
About 400,000 votes came in and it was close enough to demand a final run-off. A choice will now be made between second place “Seoul for you” (favoured by Koreans) and frontrunner “Seoul, my soul” (the preferred choice among international voters). It’s clearly difficult to find a line that will please everyone.
But perhaps the main question is: does it really matter? Many people probably don’t know whether their cities have a slogan; those who do are usually only aware when a tagline is bad enough to attract unwelcome attention. There were howls of indignation when a plan was hatched (and promptly dropped) to saddle Edinburgh with the laughable “Incredinburgh”, while poor old Eagle Pass in Texas was lumbered with the cringe-inducing “Where Yee-Haw! meets Ole!”. Perhaps the South Korean city of Busan got it right when it launched its new branding in January. Eschewing puns and clever wordplay, the new slogan gets straight to the point: “Busan is good”.
Fiona Wilson is Monocle's Tokyo bureau chief and senior Asia editor. For more opinion, analysis and insight, subscribe to Monocle today.