Opinion / René Pfister
Words of change
As we get nearer to another election cycle and look back at a historic week in US politics, a convenient explanation for Donald Trump’s victory in 2016 has taken hold among the American left. It goes like this: November 2016 expressed the last gasp of white Christian and patriarchal America, which is desperately resisting its loss of power in an increasingly diverse country.
The problem with this explanation is that it has very little to do with reality. According to analysis by the Pew Research Center, 28 per cent of all Hispanic Americans voted for Trump in 2016; four years later that figure was 38 per cent. The Republicans also made slight gains among black voters. What gave Joe Biden victory in 2020, primarily, was the change of heart among white men with college degrees. Why is this? Well, rather than winning elections, identity politics harms the political centre and the left. Trump had such success in the US – and could again – because the Democrats have lost their appeal among the working class.
Biden is among the few in his party who understand this: his most recent State of the Union address focused on social issues, such as affordable healthcare. But some Democrats seem more concerned with debating nomenclature. High-profile party members such as Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez no longer call Hispanic Americans “Latinos” but “Latinx”. A Pew Research Center survey shows that only 3 per cent of Hispanic Americans use the term. Words and acronyms such as “Bipoc” (black, indigenous and other people of colour) are meant to be inclusive but are also a marker of distinction, driving a cleaver through sections of the electorate that the Democrats claim to want to unite.
No one doubts that there is a need for a robust commitment to equality. But if politics unthinkingly submits to the dogmas of the transgender movement or the catechism of anti-racism, many people will feel bullied and turn to parties whose business model is shamelessness. The result will then not be open debate but parallel worlds that no longer communicate with each other.
René Pfister is Washington correspondent for ‘Der Spiegel’. For more opinion, analysis and insight, subscribe to Monocle today.