Opinion / Gregory Scruggs
Clean start
In September my daughter will enrol in a bilingual preschool in Seattle’s Chinatown-International District. On paper, the plan is an urbanist’s fantasy: we will cycle to the school via a “neighbourhood greenway”, a street designed to slow traffic. Once she’s inside the preschool’s seven-storey mixed-use building and I have locked my bike away, a nearby subway station will whisk me away to wherever my day leads.
On the flipside, we have to cycle past one of Seattle’s worst spots where drugs and stolen goods are openly sold on the street. Despite $1bn (€924m) of municipal expenditure on shelters and housing in the past decade, rubbish-strewn encampments – a magnet for gun violence – sprawl nearby. Sporadic police presence and infrequent arrests do little to deter the grim scene, while social-worker outreach barely makes a dent. This deadly cocktail plagues many US cities.
To fix this situation, we need urban politics to look beyond blinkered divisions. Republicans tout law and order, though they are hostile to public transport and social housing. And most municipal elections pit moderate Democrats against progressive ones. While the moderates have shown a willingness to confront urban ills, their good intentions are not enough. The progressives have abandoned the dead-end slogan “defund the police” but they still resist hiring more cops, prosecuting drug crimes and stepping up involuntary commitment. As a result, there is no political home for citizens who want increased investment in quality urbanism and stronger action on street disorder. My city feels cleaner and safer in the 18 months since mayor Bruce Harrell (pictured) took office but he shows little appetite for more housing or new rail lines.
Local leaders must prioritise the needs of the citizens who make cities vibrant. If smoking fentanyl on buses deters commuters, remove those involved. If the escalating cost of cleaning graffiti pushes shopkeepers out of business, prosecute vandalism ordinances. Compassion and tolerance, while noble ideals, have left citizens questioning the viability of their hometowns. If we want to save our cities, it takes the moral and political courage to say no.
Gregory Scruggs is a journalist based in Seattle and a regular Monocle contributor. For more city fixes, pick up the July/August issue of Monocle, or subscribe so you never miss an issue.