Opinion / Christopher Cermak
In select company
We journalists betray political predilections at our own risk but I will happily reveal that in 2000, during the US presidential election, I backed Green Party candidate Ralph Nader. After the results came in, the Democrats blamed Nader voters for costing their candidate, Al Gore, the presidency. I resented their reasoning because my pick would have been Republican George W Bush, not Gore, if Nader had not been on the ballot. Voters of third-party candidates rarely conform to a clear-cut political ideology.
Two decades on from then and there’s another new US political movement called No Labels that may sway voters who dislike the choice between Republicans and Democrats. The organisation’s supporters include bipartisan backers: centrist West Virginia senator Joe Manchin, Gore’s former vice-presidential nominee Joe Lieberman and former Utah governor Jon Huntsman (pictured, on right, with Manchin) are among them.
The movement has released a manifesto, held a town-hall debate in New Hampshire and raised more than $70m (€63m) in funding. If No Labels decides to challenge for the presidency in 2024, Huntsman suggests that a “coin flip” could decide whether a former Democrat or Republican is its nominee. The organisation has drawn criticism from both sides but mostly from Democrats who fear that it may harm Biden’s bid for re-election.
The American system does not favour third-party candidates: they typically cost established candidates elections rather than having a chance of winning themselves. But even so, alternatives are sorely needed. Nearly a fifth of registered voters would consider opting for for a “fusion” party like No Labels, a Monmouth University poll found. Third parties are commonplace in Europe, such as the UK’s Liberal Democrats. Besides that, Biden and Trump are extremely well-known entities: anyone choosing No Labels in a hyper-partisan America understands exactly what they’re doing. At a moment when democracy hangs in the balance, it’s time to welcome fresh competition into the fold.
Christopher Cermak is Monocle’s Washington correspondent. For more opinion, analysis and insight, subscribe to Monocle today.