Opinion / Fernando Augusto Pacheco
Cities on fire
I have always wanted to see a city in my native Brazil featured in Monocle’s Quality of Life Survey – but if you look at last week’s report on violent crime by the Brazilian Forum of Public Security, you’ll understand why that’s still a pipe dream. In 2022 there were 47,508 murders in the country, a number that, though astonishingly high, was the lowest since 2011.
The latest report reveals some interesting shifts. With city centres becoming more gentrified, violence has migrated to the outskirts. My own state, São Paulo, now has the lowest number of homicides per capita in Brazil. Increased funding of law enforcement and better policing have forced drug gangs to move to smaller cities, such as those in the northeast of the country, which had the highest rates of violence last year. Improved technology in areas such as forensics and body cameras has also helped. Police brutality has decreased in São Paulo as a result: the state had 419 police killings last year – which, again, though stubbornly high, is a marked improvement on recent years.
Despite Brazil’s sunny image abroad, violence is a problem that cuts across society, politics and economics. When you suffer at its hands, it can leave trauma that lasts a lifetime. More than a decade ago, when I lived in Brazil, my mother and I were kidnapped at gunpoint and held for two hours. Every time I tell my friends from abroad about this, I see the shock on their faces; in Brazil people barely bat an eyelid. If a Brazilian city is ever to feature in Monocle’s Quality of Life Survey, the country’s politicians, police and people need an effective plan to combat urban violence.
Fernando Augusto Pacheco is a senior correspondent for Monocle Radio. For more opinion, analysis and insight, subscribe to Monocle today.