By now, the content of Mike Waltz and co’s Signal chat discussing US military strikes against the Houthis has been forwarded around the world more times than the inappropriate picture that your neighbour accidentally posted on your street’s Whatsapp group. Besides being proof of the amateurism of Donald Trump’s national security team, it is also the most shocking leak to have occurred in the new government-by-smartphone era. Here in London, we have already had a few years of Whatsapp-related scandals that have revealed, among other depressing things, the extent to which high-level policy is now hashed out by politicians jackknifed over their phone screens.
Open secret: Trump’s top minds
Image: Getty Images
Perhaps it’s futile to bemoan the encroachment of technology into government decision-making or to make the point that the forum often dictates the quality of a debate: while in-person conversation doesn’t always include deep thought, instant messaging almost never does. But is it naive to expect that those entrusted with the responsibility of directing the world’s most powerful military might be a little more careful with their information? Trump’s first administration did much to erase the sacred distance previously employed by US power in order to govern effectively. It was also leakier than a wicker colander. But the second time around – and I say this in the knowledge that we’re barely more than two months in – his team has felt a lot tighter. Much has been attributed to the presence of certain “responsible people” in the room, such as the White House chief of staff, Susie Wiles.
The reason why this Signal leak hasn’t been as damaging as it might otherwise have been is the accidental presence of a responsible person in the room: The Atlantic’s editor in chief, Jeffrey Goldberg, who was handed the scoop of a lifetime but refused to disclose those elements of the chat, such as the name of a serving CIA officer, that would have put any individuals in harm’s way. European feelings were not so diligently protected. The views of the US secretary of defence, Pete Hegseth, and others towards America’s erstwhile allies were writ large in black, white and flexed-arm emojis. As for what Vlad at the other end of the street will have thought as he swiftly forwarded the messages to Xi nextdoor, one need not stretch their imagination too far to picture a devilish smile being slowly drawn across a heavily Botoxed face. While the US descends further into the realms of satire, the rest of the world, like our leaders, are forced to stare incredulously at our screens.
Alexis Self is Monocle’s foreign editor. For more opinion, analysis and insight,
subscribe
to Monocle today.