Opinion / Chiara Rimella
No joke
Comedians make cracking campaigners (see story, below). So much so that, as the rise of Beppe Grillo’s Five Star Movement in Italy proves, they often have a very good chance of winning. In the formulaic, repetitive and seemingly endless run-up to elections, satire is a powerful political tool to keep voters’ interest piqued. It’s also an excellent way to hold power to account, disrupt the status quo and inspire change.
The problem begins when the joke lands a bit too well. We want our politicians to be personable, engaging and, yes, sometimes even funny. But the job of leading a country (diplomatic negotiations, budget proposals and trade deals) is no laughing matter. Grillo’s story teaches us that the two professions are mutually exclusive: not because comedians can’t be good politicians, but because politicians can’t be comedians.
Grillo’s most recent theatre tour just wrapped up in Genoa; the script included criticism of the party he founded (and from which he now takes a back seat). It’s an odd contradiction that whiffs of hypocrisy. Comedians-turned-politicians might find they enjoy their new vocation – but perhaps it’s best if they forget about their old one.