Opinion / Lyndee Prickitt
Spat of the land
For nearly 60 days, tens of thousands of Indian farmers have occupied roads leading to New Delhi, setting up camps with trucks, tractors, horses and cows, and massive makeshift kitchens. Most say that they have no intention of leaving until the government repeals three new laws purporting to give farmers more market freedom but which farmers fear will benefit big business. Now the farmers are vowing to enter the capital tomorrow, India’s Republic Day, for a tractor rally that could increase tension in the capital and has police on high alert.
India’s antiquated agriculture sector needs reform: many of its laws and practices were born out of an age of scarcity and state socialism, which does little to propel India into the global economy. But it’s also true that most of those who work in India’s agriculture sector, which by some estimates support more than half of its 1.4 billion people, are poorly educated and own less than two hectares of land.
The government argues that the new laws will foster private trade over state-regulated markets and open up contract farming between producers and companies. The protesting farmers, however, worry that this will give too much power to big retailers. They’re also concerned that the minimum-price support policy for rice and wheat will be dismantled. It’s an understandable worry but the system has also disincentivised farmers, mostly from India’s “wheat belt” states of Haryana and Punjab, from growing other crops. This means a perennial glut of rotting wheat and rice, never mind depleted groundwater, nutrient-low soil and polluted air from the burning of rice stubble.
So there is cause for change. But if reforms are to be embraced by the public, then Narendra Modi and his government, which many feel rushed the process without any coalition-building and then took a heavy-handed response to the protests, will have to find a compromise. That should involve applying a human touch to reforms that are currently seen as heartless by those most affected.
Prickitt is a freelance journalist and regular contributor to Monocle based in New Delhi.