Opinion / Alexander Zhuravlyov
Truth hurts
More than a month after the start of the war between Russia and Ukraine, my own reaction has shifted through a wide range of emotions: denial, anger, bargaining, depression, acceptance and, finally, analysis. Through all of that came the realisation that, unlike many Russian expats such as myself, a vast majority of people inside Russia do not want to know the truth about the war. This was the hardest fact to accept – and even harder to explain. But here goes.
A friend of mine, a young woman in St Petersburg, absolutely refuses to acknowledge both the tragic events taking place on the frontline and those around her in everyday life. For her, like millions of others, it has become a matter of mental self-preservation to believe that closed shops will reopen soon, the shelves will somehow be quickly restocked and everything will get back to normal in no time. It would be an oversimplification to say that she is a victim of state propaganda. Rather, she is a living example of what it’s like to exist in a post-truth society. She declares that everyone around her is lying or being paid to lie and that it is impossible to trust anyone except her immediate circle of friends and family.
For such people in Russia, moral considerations are immaterial; they’re only interested in keeping themselves ensconced in a comfortable bubble by negating reality. State propagandists know and use this to their advantage. The state TV channels work to create fantastic stories about nationalists and fascists in Ukraine, about Pentagon-run biolaboratories directed against ethnic Russians. The purpose of these fantasies is to create a distorted sense of togetherness, of being besieged by an external, hostile world. The question is whether anything can burst through this bubble as the war continues. That could lead to civil outrage and collapse of the present regime – but only if Russians are willing to accept reality.
Alexander Zhuravlyov is a Russian-born journalist who spent 30 years working for the BBC Russian Service in London.