Opinion / Carlota Rebelo
Finding new purpose
A building’s legacy lasts for far longer than its original identity. Across Europe and indeed much of the world, symbols of dictatorships, fascism and brutal wars are scattered across cities and can be seen in train stations, friezes and statues. It’s no surprise that, for municipalities and local governments, the question of what to do with one’s controversial building stock is a tricky one to answer.
Berlin has been grappling with the problem for the past 33 years as it debates the future of the city’s former Stasi headquarters (pictured). The vast complex comprises more than 100,000 sq m of office space in a prime location, sitting directly on the U5 U-Bahn line in Lichtenberg. In a city with a significant housing shortage, it’s no wonder that the issue of what to do with the building is a contentious one. Yet reluctant owners and bureaucracy continue to prevent any serious urban intervention from going ahead. In 2020 local authorities announced that the area would be known as a “Campus for Democracy” and become home to archives and an open-air exhibition space (alongside the existing Stasi museum), leaving the rest of the vast, vacant office complex boarded up.
This is a process replicated by other European nations. In Italy, for example, the Palazzo Della Civiltà Italiana was built as a celebration of fascist architecture, yet now houses the headquarters of fashion powerhouse Fendi. It can be hard to decide what to do with controversial urban legacies; there are emotions, history and social aspects to consider. But is allowing such buildings to sit empty instead of claiming them back for your city really the right thing to do? There’s a lesson here. Taking something from a dark period of a nation’s past and turning it into something new has the potential to create a brighter future.
Carlota Rebelo is Monocle Radio’s senior foreign correspondent and the producer of ‘The Urbanist’, Monocle Radio’s weekly podcast dedicated to cities and the built environment. For more opinion, analysis and insight, subscribe to Monocle today.